19

A recent investigation by a German consumer group has uncovered serious issues with the vast majority of children’s supplements sold across Europe. Of 18 popular products tested, 17 were found to have concerning ingredients, including dangerous nutrient levels that exceed safe limits for children. The findings have raised alarms among health experts and have led to urgent warnings for parents to reconsider giving supplements to their children without consulting a doctor.

The investigation, carried out by Stiftung Warentest, a Berlin-based consumer watchdog, tested a wide range of vitamins and minerals designed to support children’s nutrition. The supplements are often marketed as beneficial for growth, immunity, and overall well-being. However, Stiftung Warentest’s findings suggest that these products, far from supporting child health, may be doing more harm than good.

High Dosages and Potential Risks

One of the most alarming discoveries from the investigation was that 15 out of the 18 supplements contained nutrient levels that exceeded the safe limits for children. Some products, particularly those with vitamin A, contained doses that surpassed even the adult maximum recommended intake, raising concerns about the long-term effects of such high levels on children’s health.

Vitamin A, when taken in excess, can be toxic, leading to nausea, dizziness, and other severe health issues. The consumer group concluded that many of these supplements, while promising to support healthy development, were “at best pointless and at worst hazardous.” The German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR) echoed this conclusion, stating that children who eat a balanced diet generally do not need supplements. The BfR also warned that no supplement can compensate for a poor or unbalanced diet, especially when used without medical supervision.

The Growing Popularity of Supplements

Despite the risks, supplements remain extremely popular in Germany and across Europe. A 2022 study found that 93% of adults in 14 EU countries had used supplements in the previous year. While the majority of consumers cited general wellness as the reason for taking supplements, many did so without a specific medical need or consultation with a healthcare professional.

In Germany, the rise in supplement use has been fueled in part by aggressive marketing tactics. Supplement companies often advertise their products as a way to boost immunity, improve development, and enhance children’s overall health. These marketing strategies, according to Stiftung Warentest, frequently rely on emotional appeals rather than solid scientific evidence, leading parents to make decisions based on feelings of concern rather than facts.

Dr. Berthold Koletzko, a pediatric specialist in Munich and president of the European Academy of Paediatrics, responded to the findings by acknowledging that, in most cases, children do not need supplements when they follow a varied and balanced diet. However, he noted that certain children, such as those on restrictive diets or living in areas with limited sunlight, may benefit from supplements, particularly for nutrients like vitamin D or calcium.

A study from 2017 revealed that 3.4% of German children between the ages of 6 and 17 followed vegetarian diets, which may have increased the risk of certain nutritional deficiencies. Koletzko anticipates that this number has risen in recent years, further highlighting the importance of proper nutritional intake for growing children.

Marketing Tactics and Misleading Claims

The Stiftung Warentest investigation also raised concerns about the marketing tactics used by supplement companies. Many products are marketed to parents using idealized images and exaggerated claims that play on emotional triggers. These advertisements often suggest that children’s health and well-being could be at risk without the use of supplements.

In addition to misleading claims, some marketing strategies violate legal standards. For example, some products were advertised as essential for a child’s immune system or development, even though the scientific evidence supporting such claims was either limited or non-existent. These findings have led to calls for stronger regulation of the children’s supplement industry to protect consumers from misleading information.

The Dangers of Gummy Vitamins and Overconsumption

Dr. Koletzko also raised concerns about the popularity of gummy vitamins, which are often marketed as an appealing option for children due to their candy-like appearance. While gummy vitamins may seem like a fun way for children to take their daily supplements, they come with risks. Many gummy vitamins contain high levels of sugar, which can contribute to childhood obesity and dental problems if consumed in excess. Moreover, the child-friendly appearance of these vitamins may lead children to overeat them, potentially causing vitamin overdose and digestive issues, including loose stools.

The doctor strongly emphasized the importance of consulting a pediatrician before offering any supplements to children. Even if a child appears to need a particular nutrient, parents should carefully select supplements and ensure they are appropriate for the child’s age and health condition. Koletzko advised parents to choose supplements with caution and always consult with a healthcare provider before starting any supplement regimen.

A Call for Caution and Medical Consultation

While many parents may feel tempted to provide supplements in the hope of boosting their child’s health, experts stress that the best way to support a child’s development is through a balanced diet rich in fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and lean proteins. For most children, a well-rounded diet provides all the essential nutrients needed for optimal growth.

In situations where supplements may be necessary, such as for children with dietary restrictions, a healthcare professional should always be consulted to ensure the appropriate product and dosage. Dr. Koletzko summed up the message, urging parents: “Select supplements carefully and always consult your child’s pediatrician first.”

The Path Forward

The findings from Stiftung Warentest serve as an important reminder that not all supplements are created equal, and many marketed to children may not be necessary or safe. As the popularity of supplements continues to grow, it is crucial that parents remain vigilant and make informed decisions based on reliable medical advice rather than the promises made in advertisements.