Silke Mayr A tribunal has ruled that the Premier League’s sponsorship regulations from 2021 to 2024 are “void and unenforceable.” This ruling follows a legal challenge made by Manchester City, which opposed parts of the league’s Associated Party Transaction (APT) regulations. The decision from the independent arbitration panel could have major implications for the Premier League and its financial rules.
Despite the setback, the Premier League maintains that the current APT rules, introduced in December 2021, are still “valid and enforceable.” The league insists these regulations remain “in full force” and that clubs must comply with them.
The Dispute Over Sponsorships and Fair Market Value
The Premier League introduced the APT regulations to prevent clubs from benefiting from sponsorship deals deemed above “fair market value.” These rules target deals linked to club owners to ensure commercial agreements do not bypass financial regulations.
However, several clubs, including Manchester City, Newcastle United, Nottingham Forest, and Aston Villa, opposed the rules. In November 2024, despite objections, the Premier League amended the regulations. The tribunal’s recent ruling does not affect these November amendments, which remain valid. However, they too are subject to a separate legal challenge.
A Significant Setback for the Premier League
The tribunal concluded that the APT rules, including the amended versions, were unlawful in three key areas. The issues could not be separated from the rest of the regulations, meaning the entire APT framework became void.
This ruling is a significant setback for the Premier League. It makes the APT rules ineffective until November 2024. The decision could lead clubs impacted by these rules to seek compensation. Sources suggest the Premier League and its clubs may now face legal liabilities worth tens of millions of pounds. This ruling also raises questions about the role of Premier League chief executive Richard Masters, who approved the amendments despite warnings from Manchester City and Aston Villa.
Premier League’s Response
The Premier League responded by stressing that the ruling does not affect the new APT regulations. The league emphasized that the tribunal did not rule on the legality of the revised rules. The Premier League believes these amended regulations are “valid and enforceable.” It is pushing for a quick resolution to the ongoing legal challenge.
The league reiterated that clubs must follow all rules, including submitting shareholder loans for fair market value assessments.
Origins of the Dispute
The dispute began in December 2021 when the Premier League introduced the APT regulations after Newcastle’s Saudi-led takeover. The league gained authority to assess sponsorship deals to ensure they were within fair market value. The aim was to prevent clubs from inflating deal values, which could allow them to bypass financial rules.
In previous legal battles, tribunals found that low-interest shareholder loans should not be included in the APT framework. One tribunal also determined that some of the Premier League’s regulatory changes violated competition laws.
Manchester City criticized the league for suggesting quick adjustments to the rules. The club opposed a vote on amendments before further arbitration. Despite this, the Premier League approved amendments in November. The revisions aimed to refine the assessment of shareholder loans and modify some earlier APT rules.
Earlier this month, Manchester City launched a new legal challenge. The club argues that the revised rules remain “unlawful.” The ongoing legal battle is expected to continue, with Manchester City and other clubs resisting the Premier League’s financial regulations.
A Potential Crisis for the Premier League
The tribunal’s ruling presents the Premier League with new financial risks. The league has already spent millions of pounds on legal disputes over financial regulations. Following the ruling, clubs could seek compensation for undervalued or rejected sponsorship deals.
If the tribunal later finds the amended APT rules unenforceable, the Premier League could face a crisis. Clubs like Manchester City and Newcastle United may secure more lucrative deals with state-linked companies. This could undermine the competitive balance of the league, as rivals worry about the advantage wealthy clubs might gain.
The Premier League also faces increased scrutiny over its governance. The league must address the fallout from the tribunal’s decision while ensuring it responds effectively to ongoing challenges.
The Future of the Premier League and Its Governance
The Premier League is already bracing for a major ruling in the disciplinary case against Manchester City. The club, facing 115 charges of financial rule breaches, denies any wrongdoing. The coming weeks could bring another landmark decision that shapes the future governance and financial structure of the league.
The Premier League’s regulatory framework remains under intense scrutiny. The tribunal’s ruling is just the latest chapter in an ongoing debate about the financial rules in English football. The outcome of the league’s legal challenges will have lasting effects on how the Premier League operates.
For the latest updates on this story, visit Financial Mirror.